Sefer Torat Moshe
There has long been a discussion between people who believe that the Mosaic authorship of the Torah is proven by the Torah itself when it refers to "Torat Moshe", the Torah of Moses. Their opponents argue that this is a generic term which implies some "teaching" or "instruction" and does not mean the notion of the Pentateuch as we know it.
It seems to me that the latter argument is strengthened by the contents of the Book of Joshua. Chapter 8, verse 30 states:
It takes a scribe about a year to write a Torah using ink and scroll. It is not clear from the text whether the writing was engraved into the stones or written on it, but it is clear from the text that this effort did not take very long. Furthermore, the reading of the entire "Torah of Moses" implies that this is not the same Torah that we know today.
Comments, questions, concerns?
It seems to me that the latter argument is strengthened by the contents of the Book of Joshua. Chapter 8, verse 30 states:
It takes a scribe about a year to write a Torah using ink and scroll. It is not clear from the text whether the writing was engraved into the stones or written on it, but it is clear from the text that this effort did not take very long. Furthermore, the reading of the entire "Torah of Moses" implies that this is not the same Torah that we know today.
Comments, questions, concerns?
3 Comments:
You are right.
Since this story didn't happen, it doesn't actually prove very much.
It's more than just the time it would take to write. As is known, the word Torah is only found in the book of Deuteronomy in the Pentateuch. There this term refers to some/all of this book. This is the traditional understanding of the term and is supported within the context of its use. As for the term here in Joshua, we see that all the laws mentioned here are those of Deuteronomy, it's reasonable to suppose that the termis used in the same vain here.
Post a Comment
<< Home